What are you adding to the tray?
the zodiac as Christmas cookies, a blog by libbertie richmond
Holiday cookies come in all kinds of personalities. Some are nostalgic and familiar, some are bold and attention-grabbing, and others are a little unexpected—but somehow essential. Much like the zodiac, no two are quite the same, and each one brings its own energy to the season.
We matched each zodiac sign with a Christmas cookie that reflects its vibe, quirks, and charm. Because whether you’re a tried-and-true favorite or a surprise standout, the cookie tray wouldn’t be complete without you. So… which one are you?
Aries are bold, impulsive, and far too busy chasing their next adventure to fuss with anything delicate, cookies included. That’s why the Monster Cookie is their perfect match. It’s bright, playful, quick to whip up, and packed with candy chunks that mirror their childlike, firecracker energy. Sure, some people say there’s a lot going on in a Monster Cookie… but honestly, that’s exactly the point. If there wasn’t a lot going on, an Aries would lose interest in about three seconds flat.
The Peanut Butter Blossom is pure nostalgia wrapped in sugar, cozy, comforting, and reliably delicious every single time. With its perfect trio of peanut butter, chocolate, and sparkly sugar, it warms your heart before you even take a bite. And let’s be honest: it’s adorable. That iconic little chocolate kiss in the middle? Chef’s kiss.
It’s no surprise this cookie pairs perfectly with Taurus, ruled by Venus, the planet of beauty and simple pleasures. Not too plain, not too extra, just the right amount of charm. And somehow, it always ends up on your plate… right where a Taurus likes it.
The Brookie is the ultimate Gemini cookie, because why choose when you can have both? Just like the twins of the zodiac, Geminis are all about duality, versatility, and mixing things up. A brookie blends a cookie and a brownie into one irresistible bite, perfectly mirroring Gemini’s love of variety, shifting interests, and endless curiosity.
Every brookie comes out a little different, fun, quirky, and full of personality, just like them. Their bold uniqueness and creative swirl of flavors make this treat the ideal match for a Gemini’s multifaceted spirit.
Cancers are the Ginger Snap of the cookie world. Not quite a gingerbread, not exactly a snickerdoodle, but something special all their own. Classic, cozy, and perfectly spiced, the ginger snap wraps you in warmth… but don’t forget that little bite it packs. That’s Cancer energy to a tee.
If you know a Cancer, you know they’re nurturing and comforting, but they also carry a protective streak and a sharp little “snap” when needed. They’re not trying to be the flashiest cookie on the plate, but somehow the ginger snap always finds a way into our hearts, and so do Cancers.
Leos are the Pinwheel Swirl Christmas Cookie, bright, bold, and impossible to ignore. With their vibrant colors and flawless spirals, these cookies command attention the moment they hit the plate. When executed well, the aesthetic is unbeatable, and no one can deny their star power.
Like true Leos, pinwheels take up space, shine under the spotlight, and instantly elevate the whole cookie spread just by being there. Sure, some bakers shy away because they’re tricky to perfect but when you do nail them, they’re an absolute showstopper. Exactly the kind of energy a Leo brings to any room.
Virgo is the Sugar Cookie—clean, classic, and executed with flawless precision. One look at this cookie and you can spot the perfection: smooth frosting, crisp edges, meticulous piping, and a design that’s simple yet incredibly intentional.
Anyone who’s baked sugar cookies knows they’re a delicate science, exact measurements, careful timing, and steady hands. In other words… peak Virgo energy. If a Virgo is making them, expect perfectly iced shapes, detailed designs, and a beautifully color-coordinated theme. And absolutely never a dry cookie.
Sugar cookies may look effortless, but that elegance comes from skill, care, and an attention to detail that only a Virgo could truly master.
Libras are all about balance and harmony—and what better match than gravy? Like Libra, gravy brings everything together, blending effortlessly with every part of the meal. It’s the finishing touch, the peacemaker on your plate. And just like Libras, gravy wants everyone to get along—and for everyone to like it, too.
Scorpios are the Dark Chocolate Peppermint Cookie, rich, intense, and undeniably deep. This cookie has layers: a cool, sharp peppermint bite that wakes up your senses, wrapped in dark, decadent chocolate that feels almost forbidden. It’s bold, it’s indulgent, and it’s not here to play it safe.
Some people can’t even finish one because it can be a lot, but that’s the point. Scorpios aren’t for the faint of heart. For those who grow to love the depth, the richness, and the deliciously dark complexity, this cookie becomes the standout favorite on the entire plate.
Sagittarius is the Candy Cane Cookie, not to be confused with the chunk-filled version. Bold, bright, and endlessly creative, Sagittarians have the same fun, twisted pattern that makes the candy cane cookie instantly recognizable. They break molds (or in this case, the cookie cutter) and aren’t afraid to stand out with color, flair, and boldness.
Just like the classic red-and-white swirl, Sagittarius energy is vibrant and engaging. And if your candy cane cookie has a touch of peppermint? That’s the perfect nod to the spice, zest, and excitement they bring to every adventure.
Capricorns are the Thumbprint Cookie, understated, classic, and far better than many people realize at first glance. Some folks don’t even know what they’re looking at, or assume it’s too simple to be interesting. But anyone who actually tries one quickly learns the truth: the balance is perfect, the flavors are spot-on, and the whole thing works without trying to be anything it’s not.
Thumbprint cookies don’t need flash or hype, they shine through their reliability, craftsmanship, and quietly confident flavor. That’s peak Capricorn energy. Traditional, but not in the obvious nostalgic way; classic, but in a refined, curated, uniquely Capricorn way. If you’ve never had one… it’s time.
The Gingerbread Man Cookie is pure Aquarius energy, fun, imaginative, and unlike anything else on the plate. Each one is completely unique, dressed up in candy, icing, chocolate, or whatever wild creative vision the baker dreams up. No two ever look alike, and that’s exactly the point.
More craft project than classic cookie, the gingerbread man leans into creativity, individuality, and a little delightful weirdness. It breaks tradition, bends the rules, and becomes its own tiny work of art. And honestly? That unconventional, free-spirited vibe is exactly why it’s the perfect match for our brilliant, one-of-a-kind Aquarians.